Brain research and Nazi crimes
Findings of the historical research project now available
An independent collaborative research project, which set out to identify the victims of Nazi "euthanasia" and other forms of Nazi persecution whose brain specimens were collected for scientific purposes at two Max Planck Institutes, formerly Kaiser Wilhelm Institutes, has concluded after nine years. The project, funded by the Max Planck Society, was prompted by the discovery of brain tissue sections in the Archive of the Max Planck Society in Berlin and in the Historical Archive of the Max Planck Institute of Psychiatry in Munich. Clarifying the provenance of these specimens, and the research contexts in which they were produced and used, was a central objective of the project. The findings were published by Wallstein Verlag in September and will be presented at book launches in Berlin on 20 October and in Munich on 16 November 2026.
The Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Brain Research in Berlin-Buch (KWIH) and the German Research Institute for Psychiatry (Deutsche Forschungsanstalt für Psychiatrie, DFA) in Munich acquired thousands of brain specimens from victims of Nazi crimes for use in their research. After the war, the collections established at the time remained with the Institutes for Brain Research and Psychiatry, which were now working under the umbrella of the Max Planck Society (MPG). Their origins were not subjected to critical scrutiny. The individuals whose brain specimens continued to be misused in scientific research for decades were, to a large extent, victims of Nazi "euthanasia", the systematic murder of people with mental illnesses or disabilities. Other specimens came from Jewish and non-Jewish victims of the German occupation of Poland, prisoners of war of various nationalities, forced labourers and victims of the Nazi judicial system. A central aim of the research project was to recover the names of these individuals and make them public and, where possible, reconstruct their biographies.
The project, entitled "Brain Research at Institutes of the Kaiser Wilhelm Society in the context of National Socialist injustices: brain specimens at Institutes of the Max Planck Society and the identification of the victims", was initially led by Herwig Czech (Medical University of Vienna, MedUni Vienna), Gerrit Hohendorf (Technical University of Munich) and Paul Weindling (Oxford Brookes University). Following the sudden death of Gerrit Hohendorf, leadership of the Munich sub-project passed to Philipp Rauh (Technical University of Munich) and Volker Roelcke (University of Giessen), who had also helped to develop the overall project and prepare the funding application. Patricia Heberer-Rice of the US Holocaust Memorial Museum served as an adviser.
Findings of the sub-projects focusing on victims of "euthanasia" (MedUni Vienna in cooperation with Charité Berlin, led by Herwig Czech; and the Technical University of Munich, led by Philipp Rauh and Volker Roelcke, University of Giessen)
At the two neuropathological institutes of the Kaiser Wilhelm Society (KWG) in Berlin and Munich, at least 1,356 brains were received from people who had been murdered between 1939 and 1945 as part of the Nazi "euthanasia" programme. For the KWIH, the historians identified 926 victims of "euthanasia", just under half of all the brains that entered the collection during the Second World War. The Institute of Brain Pathology (HPI) at the DFA in Munich was sent brain specimens from 1,388 people suspected of being victims of Nazi "euthanasia". In 430 cases, this suspicion was confirmed. It was not always possible, however, to establish the exact circumstances of death with certainty, because the surviving documentary record was in some cases incomplete or contradictory. The actual figures may therefore be even higher. Of the 1,356 victims of Nazi "euthanasia" whose brains entered the two collections during the period studied, 647 – almost half – were children under the age of ten.
Nazi crimes, "euthanasia" and science
The research group concluded that staff at the KWG institutes not only placed their expertise in the service of Nazi policies on hereditary health and race, but also benefited considerably from the eugenically and racially motivated policy of extermination pursued by the Nazi state. The analysis of specimens deemed of scientific interest was by no means confined to the period up to the end of the Second World War: research findings based on specimens from victims of "euthanasia" continued to be published in scientific journals long after 1945.
Herwig Czech, project leader from MedUni Vienna, puts it starkly: "During the Nazi era, neuropathology in Germany took advantage of virtually every opportunity to obtain brains and other tissue for research, not least the mass murder of individuals with cognitive disabilities and mental illnesses. Institutes of what was then the Kaiser Wilhelm Society were among the most active. It was a grave ethical failure that research on these specimens continued for decades after the end of the war; its results can still be found in the scientific literature today."
Under National Socialism, the relevant Kaiser Wilhelm Institutes were closely linked to psychiatric hospitals and care institutions that served as sites for the "euthanasia" murders. A key role was played by the autopsy and dissection facilities attached to the two KWG institutes, where the bodies of deceased patients were autopsied and organs removed for research. During the Second World War, the neuropathologists of the DFA drew on their contacts with the Kinderfachabteilungen ("specialist children’s wards") of Bavarian care institutions, a euphemism for a designated killing ward in the context of the "child euthanasia" programme. The KWIH in Berlin received, among other things, the brains of children and adolescents from the Brandenburg-Görden state psychiatric hospital who had previously been murdered in the "children’s ward" there. Specimens also arrived from the gassing centres of "Aktion T4". The staff of the Histopathological Department of the KWIH, including its head Julius Hallervorden, were not merely privy to the killings but also scientific beneficiaries of them. In at least one documented case, Hallervorden was also personally present at the Brandenburg killing centre to remove brains immediately after the murders. There is also strong evidence that researchers lent scientific legitimacy to the "euthanasia" crimes with their expertise and geared their research questions towards sharpening the selection criteria.
Research and the handling of the collections after 1945
The principal scientists responsible –Julius Hallervorden, Hugo Spatz and Willibald Scholz –were able to continue their work at the Max Planck Society after 1945 without hindrance. Their protégés succeeded them in the leadership positions at the two Institutes. This continuity of personnel not only prevented a critical view of the Nazi-era history of the specimen collections; it also facilitated the deliberate concealment of that history. Maximilian Buschmann, a research associate on the project: "Continuity of personnel, together with the fact that later generations of researchers also paid no attention to where the specimens had come from, made it possible for the murder of these individuals to be concealed, denied and repressed time and again at the Max Planck Institute of Psychiatry after 1945."
In the post-war decades, the collections were used not only by researchers at the Max Planck Institute for Brain Research and the Max Planck Institute of Psychiatry; the specimens were also made available, without scruple, to other German and international researchers. The historians were able to demonstrate that knowledge gained from research on the specimens found its way into specialist scientific publications on multiple occasions. Their research identified at least 84 publications, most of them in neuropathology appearing between 1940 and 1996 that demonstrably relied on the scientific use of tissue samples and data from victims of Nazi "euthanasia". There are at least a further 256 publications in which the use of specimens from victims of "euthanasia" appears probable.
The collections lost significance only when neuroscience methods evolved in the 1970s. In In 1990, the MPG arranged for the burial of specimens at Munich’s Waldfriedhof cemetery. The Max Planck Institutes evidently parted with their Nazi-era holdings chiefly because the declining relevance of the neuropathological and morphological approach coincided with efforts at historical reappraisal and the growing political and moral pressure on the MPG that accompanied them. The project’s findings make clear that the burial at the time was incomplete.
Volker Roelcke, project leader from the University of Giessen, comments on the project’s contemporary relevance: "The findings contribute to bioethical debates about medical research that, in the process of generating knowledge, fails to consider the origins of its “objects of investigation”. In such research, the production of new knowledge takes the highest priority, while other considerations – such as upholding humanitarian standards in knowledge production or showing regard for the health and wellbeing of those from whom data are collected – are neglected."
Sub-project focusing on other groups of victims of unethical neuropathological research under National Socialism (project leader: Paul Weindling, Oxford Brookes University)
Until now, the extent to which the exploitation of brains and nerve tissue from non-Germans for research purposes was unethical during and after the Second World War has been overlooked. The research project led by Paul Weindling addressed this neglected group of victims for the first time, reconstructing the biographies and circumstances of death of 314 individuals whose brains entered the collections of the KWIH in Berlin-Buch and the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Psychiatry / German Research Institute for Psychiatry (DFA) in Munich between 1933 and 1945. These individuals were victims of the German occupation of Poland, Belgium, and France; Allied prisoners of war who were victims of war crimes; forced labourers; other victims of the Nazi regime; and people executed in Nazi Germany for acts that were punishable under the law of the time. A particularly large group of victims, numbering 183 people, consisted of civilians from Poland, 139 of them Jewish victims.
Particular mention should be made of the brain samples from 237 victims in Julius Hallervorden’s wartime collection of "military samples" (the so-called Series M). A surprising finding was that these, too, included samples from civilians; 74 of these victims were women. The series originally also included the fluid-preserved specimens of two Polish Jews and a French prisoner of war. The team of historians discovered these in the former display collection of the Neurological Institute (Edinger Institute) of the University of Frankfurt am Main. Links in personnel between that institute and the Max Planck Institute for Brain Research after the Second World War had led to parts of the collection being transferred there.
The great majority of the human specimens examined by the group were destroyed without burial in the early 1980s; a small proportion was interred in 1990. The group also found that microscope slides of nerve tissue from a further 56 people, unethically obtained, belonged to the scientific collection of the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Psychiatry (later the Max Planck Institute of Psychiatry) in Munich. Tissue sections from 38 of these individuals are still held there.
Paul Weindling’s research group was also responsible for establishing a database at the German National Academy of Sciences Leopoldina. It systematically records the names, dates and documents of victims of unethical medical research under National Socialism, documenting them for research and enquiries. Data on around 1,900 people, collected in the course of the research project on the KWG and MPG, have also been entered into the database.
Remembering the victims
The historical reappraisal has now produced two scholarly monographs and two books of remembrance containing the names and biographies of the victims. They provide the substantive basis for shaping the MPG’s culture of remembrance in the coming years. The starting point is the decision by the Max Planck Society, also recommended by the project’s historians, to name the victims and to make their fates and biographies visible, so as to preserve the memory of these individuals and to acknowledge their suffering and that of their families.
MPG President Patrick Cramer states: "The historians’ findings fill us with deep shame, for they demonstrate that researchers, in their pursuit of knowledge, acted without respect for human dignity – both during National Socialism and afterwards. By remembering, by name, the individuals whose organs were unlawfully retained in the pathological collections of our Institutes and misused for research, we wish to take responsibility for the wrong that was done and to acknowledge the profound suffering of the victims and their families. The memory of the crimes of National Socialism, in which science also played a role, remains a constant admonition that respect for human beings, for their dignity and their inalienable rights, must always take precedence over the pursuit of scientific knowledge."
Burial and memorial site at Munich’s Waldfriedhof
At the Max Planck Institute of Psychiatry, the specimens of a total of 139 victims of National Socialism that have not yet been buried are being prepared for a dignified burial. In consultation with relatives and organisations representing victims, they are to be laid to rest in Munich’s Waldfriedhof cemetery in the coming years.
To this end, the memorial site that has stood there since 1990 is to be redesigned as a place of remembrance for the victims. It is also intended to prompt necessary reflection on the ethical limits of research, informed by insight into the historical crimes committed by directors of the Kaiser Wilhelm Society and the Max Planck Society. Moritz Helmstaedter, Director at the Max Planck Institute for Brain Research, sees in this a particular obligation: "The scale of the crimes documented in the historical works now available, and the fact that they were deliberately planned by directors of what later became the Max Planck Institute for Brain Research, are a heavy burden for our Institute. Through the "Never Forget" memorial, which we had erected in 2022 at the centre of our institute in Frankfurt am Main, we also wish to keep alive the memory of these crimes and of their victims, and the continuing admonition they represent for our scientific work."
To prepare for the burial, the President of the MPG has appointed a commission bringing together experts in the culture of remembrance and in human remains, historians and ethicists, with representatives of affected families and self-advocacy organisations of those affected. It is chaired by Elisabeth Binder, Director at the Max Planck Institute of Psychiatry. The commission’s central task is to develop an institutional position for the Max Planck Society and its institutes on the historical crimes and on the long absence of any critical reappraisal, so as to live up to its historical responsibility.
The commission will guide the shaping of the culture of remembrance within the Max Planck Society and will coordinate closely with relatives, and with organisations representing the different groups of victims, on the redesign of the memorial site and the arrangements for the burial. "We want the discussion within the President’s Commission to be understood, with the greatest possible transparency, as part of our culture of remembrance from the very beginning," says Elisabeth Binder. "For far too long we have failed to undertake a critical reappraisal of our history, so our key aim now is to proceed transparently and to involve everyone concerned, most importantly the descendants of the victims. Honouring the victims, making their individual fates visible and giving them a dignified burial are central to this."
Events
Two complementary events in Berlin and Munich will present the findings of the research project on the victims, with different thematic and regional emphases.
20 October 2026 │ 7 pm │ Berlin
Speakers: Patrick Cramer, President of the Max Planck Society; Herwig Czech, Medical University of Vienna; Carol Day and Alison MacPhail, nieces of a victim (UK); Paul Weindling, Oxford Brookes University
Welcome address: Andrea Riedle, Director of the Topography of Terror Foundation
Panel moderator: Maike Rotzoll, Institute of the History of Pharmacy and Medicine, University of Marburg
Venue and cooperation partners
Topography of Terror Documentation Centre, Berlin
Niederkirchnerstraße 8
10963 Berlin
16 November 2026 │ 7 pm │ Munich
Speakers: Patrick Cramer, President of the Max Planck Society; Philipp Rauh and Maximilian Buschmann, Technical University of Munich; Volker Roelcke, University of Giessen; Ulrike Martha Zimmermann, niece of a victim and visual artist, Berlin
Welcome address: Mirjam Zadoff, Director of the Munich Documentation Centre for the History of National Socialism
Panel moderator: Maike Rotzoll, Institute of the History of Pharmacy and Medicine, University of Marburg
Venue and cooperation partners
Munich Documentation Centre for the History of National Socialism (NS-Dokumentationszentrum)
Max-Mannheimer-Platz 1
80333 Munich
